Located in Chelmsford MA, Jay Colangelo Insurance is your leading local insurance agency; dedicated to serving the diverse Massachusetts insurance needs of area individuals, families and businesses since 1996.

Over the years, Colangelo Insurance has continued to evolve into a trusted coverage leader—with impeccable service and commitment to its clients—characteristics not often found in other Massachusetts insurance agencies.

Besides our array of unique products—what really makes Colangelo Insurance stand apart? Well for one, we take the time to fully evaluate your insurance needs so that your biggest assets are protected at the most competitive rates—and we pledge that our inclusive solutions are capable of giving you the peace of mind you’ve been looking for.

At Jay Colangelo Insurance, we consider everyone and every policy to be unique—which is precisely why you need, Colangelo Insurance – the preferred choice for Massachusetts insurance companies– to create a tailored, custom policy specifically for you!

In September of 2016 Jay Colangelo Insurance Agency merged with Duffy Insurance Agency. The combined agencies will maintain the personalized customer service that you are accustomed to and expand the products and insurance company choices.

Duffy Insurance handles auto claims quickly and professionally. After my car accident, I felt lost. Duffy Insurance helped me handle the claims process and gave me support when I needed it. The service was fantastic!
Cindy, Salem, MA

Duffy Insurance truly understands our business and the insurance industry. We have developed a strong relationship with Duffy Insurance and know we can trust them to lead us in the right direction. They have been with us through our extensive growth and provided the necessary advice and services to help us reach our business goals.
Bill, Salem, MA

Latest News

Duffy Acquires N. Pingree Insurance of Georgetown and Haverhill, MA The N. Pingree Insurance Agency and its Georgetown and Haverhill MA offices has joined the Duffy Family of Insurance Agencies. N. Pingree Insurance Agency was established in 1938 by H. Nelson Pingree. The agency will continue to operate under the Pingree Insurance name.

Click here to read the press release

Duffy Insurance Acquires Jay Colangelo Insurance of Chelmsford.  The Jay Colangelo Insurance Agency was established in 1994.  James, “Jay,” Colangelo and his staff of four will remain working out of their current Chelmsford, MA location.

“We are excited to welcome the Jay Colangelo Insurance Agency to the Duffy team.  Jay and his staff have built and maintained a strong reputation and insurance agency in Chelmsford.  We look forward to working closely together with Jay and his team moving forward,” said Marc Duffy.   Click here for press release